Michael Silberling

Share this post

OP Drop #2 Thread

michaelsilberling.substack.com

OP Drop #2 Thread

Sybil hunting is an endless & winless arms race.

Michael Silberling
Feb 11
1
Share this post

OP Drop #2 Thread

michaelsilberling.substack.com

Open the thread in Twitter, or follow the text below.

Twitter avatar for @MSilb7
msilb7.bedrock 🔴✨ @MSilb7
Sybil hunting is an endless & winless arms race. Our approaches need to be attack-resistant ~by design~. Here’s how Optimism drop #2 iterates towards this:
Twitter avatar for @optimismFND
Optimism (✨🔴_🔴✨) @optimismFND
Today Optimism is announcing OP Airdrop #2. 11.7M OP distributed to over 300k unique addresses to reward positive-sum governance participation and power users of Optimism Mainnet. Read on for details on eligibility criteria and distribution. https://t.co/lgLMHqli26
9:54 PM ∙ Feb 9, 2023
98Likes12Retweets

Sybil hunting is an endless & winless arms race. Our approaches need to be attack-resistant ~by design~. Here’s how Optimism drop #2 iterates towards this:

Thanks for reading Michael Silberling! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

The rewards were structured as a function of governance delegation amount and duration, as well as a partial rebate on gas usage. Since there were no "fixed" rewards (i.e. get X for doing Y), there was little to no benefit for using many addresses.

Image

If recipients had attributes showing stronger usage, they qualified for bonuses. These were multipliers, so there was again little additional benefit from getting bonuses on many addresses versus a few.

Image

There are likely some sybil attackers who received OP rewards, but that’s fine. The way to qualify for this reward was to do things that are good for Optimism: Use the network and contribute to the Optimism Collective.

Once we accept that anything that can be gamed or exploited, will be, we can start to work to design better systems. If we can design systems that reward positive-sum behaviors and impactful contributions, imagine what we can achieve.

Speaking of designing systems where impactful contributions are rewarded, check out the Optimism Collective, and our Retroactive Public Goods Funding initiative. Impact = Profit: https://app.optimism.io/retropgf

Image

Thanks for reading Michael Silberling! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Share this post

OP Drop #2 Thread

michaelsilberling.substack.com
Comments
TopNew

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Michael Silberling
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing